Should I Replace All of My Windows at Once?

When considering replacement windows, one of the most frequently asked questions is, “Should I replace all of my windows at the same time?” The answer isn’t always a straightforward yes or no; it depends on your goals, budget and the condition of your current windows. Let’s explore the pros and cons of replacing all your windows at once and why many Wisconsin homeowners find value in tackling the project in full. 

The Benefits of a Full-Home Window Replacement

  1. Consistent Energy Efficiency

Old windows can be a significant source of energy loss, especially during Wisconsin’s frigid winters and humid summers. Replacing all of your windows at once ensures your entire home benefits from: 

  • Advanced energy-efficient materials like Fibrex®
  • Seamless weatherstripping
  • High-performance glass to reduce heat transfer

This uniform upgrade can dramatically reduce energy bills and improve indoor comfort. 

  1. Streamlined Aesthetic

If replacements are done over time, different window styles or frames can clash. Replacing all windows simultaneously provides a cohesive, modern look throughout your home, inside and out. Whether you prefer a sleek contemporary style or something more traditional, doing it all at once ensures everything matches perfectly. 

  1. Lower Cost Per Window 

Bundling your windows into one project can offer cost efficiencies. Many window companies, including Renewal by Andersen, provide promotional offers or volume-based pricing that can reduce your total investment per window. 

  1. Minimized Disruption 

One full-home window installation is often less disruptive than scheduling multiple appointments across months or years. Our certified installers can complete most full-home replacements in just a few days. 

Reasons to Consider Phased Replacement 

While replacing all windows at once offers many advantages, it’s not always feasible for every homeowner. 

  1. Budget Considerations

Window replacement is a significant investment. Some homeowners prefer to prioritize high-traffic or problem areas first, such as drafty living rooms or aging bedroom windows, and schedule the rest over time. 

  1. Urgency of Repairs 

If only a few windows are damaged or leaking, starting with those might make more sense. In fact, we often recommend addressing critical issues like moisture intrusion or rotting frames first. 

  1. Lifestyle and Schedule 

Sometimes, a full-home project doesn’t align with your family’s lifestyle or timeline. Whether you’re planning to renovate room by room or have just moved in, phased replacements may offer more flexibility. 

Our Recommendation: Start with a Consultation

If you’re unsure whether a full-home window replacement or a phased approach is best for your situation, our team at Renewal by Andersen can help you. During your free consultation, we’ll assess your current windows, discuss your energy goals, and help you prioritize what makes the most sense for your home and budget. 

Final Thoughts 

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but understanding your goals, your home’s needs, and your budget can help guide your decision. Whether you choose to replace a few windows now or all of them at once, Renewal by Andersen offers the expertise and quality to make your project a success. Schedule your free consultation today to get started! 

Hear From Our Customers

I cant express how happy we are with choosing Andersen for our window installation. Our sales representative was knowledgeable with product and answered any questions we had without hesitation. I did also fill out a survey that was sent in an email, but sadly I failed to personally name the two gentlemen that performed the actual installation. Barrett and Francisco were our guys, and let me tell you, they were outstanding!!! They did Excellent work and were professional as well as efficient and made this a smooth, none evasive process for us. I strongly recommend this company and these installers to anyone in need of windows!!! My husband and I could not be more pleased we chose Andersen for replacing our windows!!!

This was a great crew to work with. Both the original install manager we worked with (Jay) and the install team (Daniel, Mason, Tony, Ethan, and Jose). Everyone was very professional and knowledgeable. They answered all my questions and the end result on the house is great. In 3 days they replaced an old bay window with a new bay window, a set of french doors on the patio with a sliding patio door, and our old front door with a new front door and storm door.

Jason and Brett did an awesome job installing our doors. We had separate installers a month earlier for our windows who also did a fantastic job. They were all very professional and cleaned up almost better than the area looked before the installation! Since these were both jobs that took more than one day the installers were great at keeping us informed on the status of where the project was at along the way.

BUY MORE, SAVE MORE!
SAVE UP TO 35% OFF* + VIP PACKERS EXPERIENCE (ENTER TO WIN)
+
12 MONTHS NO PAYMENTS NO INTEREST NO MONEY DOWN*
Claim These Savings
ENJOY PEACE OF MIND
Green Diamond Signature Service Award
Custom Built In USA
JD Power SCS Indoor Advantage Gold Certified U.S. GREEN BUILDING COUNCIL NATIONAL FENESTRATION RATING COUNCIL CERTIFIED
GREEN SEAL CERTIFIED PRODUCTS ALLIANCE TO SAVE ENERGY
Lead Safe

Since its founding in 1977, the Alliance to Save Energy has been a leader in energy efficiency policy and advocacy. Over the years, the Alliance’s programs and priorities have evolved as U.S. energy efficiency policy has grown.